
11 Howard
Best for contemporary downtown nights out, a Michelin-starred restaurant, and event/party-driven stays.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
11 Howard is a five-star SoHo boutique hotel with a downtown, design-forward personality; read this if you want contemporary dining, nightlife, and a minimalist, adults-oriented stay. The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel is a storied Upper East Side luxury property with society and cultural cachet; read this if you prefer classic, museum- and Central-Park–side elegance and old‑world service.
Updated · about 6 km apart

Best for contemporary downtown nights out, a Michelin-starred restaurant, and event/party-driven stays.

Best for classic luxury, proximity to Central Park and the Met, and a formal, service-focused Upper East Side experience.
When 11 Howard wins: pick 11 Howard if you want a SoHo base for restaurants, nightlife (on-site bar/nightclub), contemporary design, and a more casual, younger crowd; it’s also the clearer choice for private events with several distinct event spaces and a large terrace suite.
When The Carlyle wins: choose The Carlyle for a more formal, traditional New York luxury experience, immediate access to Central Park and the city’s cultural institutions, full-service spa facilities, and a quieter, society-oriented atmosphere.
Bottom line: 11 Howard and The Carlyle both deliver five-star service but serve different moods — 11 Howard for downtown, design-led social stays; The Carlyle for classic Upper East Side refinement and museum-side convenience.
| Category | 11 Howard | The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Contemporary SoHo boutique, nightlife and design focus | Classic Upper East Side luxury with cultural and social cachet |
| Location | 11 Howard Street, SoHo — steps from Canal St, Nolita, Chinatown | 35 E 76th St — steps from Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art |
| Size (guestrooms) | 207 guest rooms and suites (published) | 188 guestrooms (published) |
| Adults policy | 21+ minimum check-in for primary guest; children welcome with qualifying adult | Not adults-only; standard all-ages policy (adults welcome) |
| Pools | No on-site pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Le Coucou (French, Michelin recognition) + The Library lounge + The Blond/Lounge nightclub/bar | Two restaurants (including Bemelman's Bar) and a bar/lounge; 24-hour room service |
| Spa & wellness | HigherDOSE on-site (infrared sauna suites, lymphatic drainage treatments; guest discount) | Full-service spa on-site (published) |
| Event space / meetings | Multiple event rooms incl. Terrace Suite, Creative Studio, Yard — ~3,600 sq ft published | Number of meeting rooms - 1 (published) with additional private and suite spaces |
| Nearby highlights | Walkable to Brooklyn/Manhattan Bridges, Chinatown, Little Italy, boutiques in Nolita | Within a 10-minute walk of Central Park, The Met, and Madison Avenue shopping |
| Parking & transport notes | On-site valet; nearest subway Canal Street ~1 block | Valet parking (surcharge); close to museums and Madison Avenue |
11 Howard sits at the crossroads of SoHo, Nolita, Chinatown and Tribeca — convenient for downtown dining, shopping and nightlife.
Choose 11 Howard if you want to be in the middle of downtown shopping, restaurants, and nightlife.
The Carlyle sits on the Upper East Side, immediately convenient for Central Park and New York’s museum row.
The Carlyle is the better choice for park-side and museum-oriented days or a quieter, classic NYC neighborhood.
11 Howard’s rooms emphasize Scandinavian minimalism, handcrafted furniture, and oversized windows.
Rooms at 11 Howard are modern and design-forward — good if you prefer contemporary interiors.
The Carlyle offers traditionally styled rooms and a range of suites with formal touches.
The Carlyle’s rooms lean toward traditional luxury and larger suite options for a formal stay.
11 Howard’s standout dining is Le Coucou plus casual Library service and a lively bar/nightclub.
Pick 11 Howard if a modern, high-profile restaurant and on-site nightlife are priorities.
The Carlyle offers traditional hotel dining and well-known bar service in a formal setting.
The Carlyle is best if you prefer classic hotel dining and a refined bar atmosphere near cultural institutions.
11 Howard focuses on indoor wellness and social terraces rather than swimming facilities.
11 Howard centers on rooftop and outdoor event spaces rather than traditional pool amenities.
The Carlyle’s listing highlights its classic hotel amenities and mentions a full-service spa; pool details are not published in the supplier listing.
The Carlyle emphasizes formal amenities and a full-service spa; pool presence is not published.
11 Howard combines HigherDOSE infrared sauna treatments with an on-site nightlife venue.
11 Howard pairs a focused wellness offering with a lively nightlife program — good for social stays with wellness options.
The Carlyle provides a traditional full-service spa and a quieter, evening-focused bar scene.
The Carlyle suits travelers who want formal spa treatments and quieter, classic hotel evenings.

11 Howard — on-site lounge/nightclub and a lively downtown neighborhood make late-night plans easy.

The Carlyle — immediate proximity to Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art.

11 Howard — Scandinavian-influenced rooms, contemporary public spaces and a design-focused program.

The Carlyle — traditional suites, formal dining and long-standing Upper East Side service culture.
The Carlyle is generally quieter and more formal in the evenings; 11 Howard sits in a busier downtown area and operates an on-site nightclub.
The Carlyle — it’s within a short walk of Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
11 Howard does not have an on-site pool; The Carlyle’s supplier listing does not publish pool details.
Both do: 11 Howard has Le Coucou (MICHELIN One Star) and The Library; The Carlyle lists two restaurants and Bemelman's Bar.
Neither property is strictly adults-only in terms of guest access; 11 Howard enforces a 21+ minimum check-in age for the primary guest while The Carlyle does not publish an adults-only policy.
Explore how 11 Howard stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·