
11 Howard
Best for travelers who want a trendy downtown base, Michelin-recognized dining (Le Coucou), and compact boutique rooms with easy access to SoHo, Chinatown, and the Brooklyn Bridge.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
11 Howard is a downtown SoHo boutique hotel with Le Coucou and a nightlife focus; read this if you want a stylish, design-forward stay near Lower Manhattan neighborhoods. The Peninsula New York is a classic Fifth Avenue five-star luxury hotel; read this if you prefer Midtown convenience, a larger full-service spa and traditional luxury service.
Updated · about 4 km apart

Best for travelers who want a trendy downtown base, Michelin-recognized dining (Le Coucou), and compact boutique rooms with easy access to SoHo, Chinatown, and the Brooklyn Bridge.

Best for travelers seeking a traditional Fifth Avenue luxury address with a full-service spa, indoor pool, multiple bars/lounges, and proximity to Midtown attractions like MoMA and Rockefeller Center.
When 11 Howard wins: choose 11 Howard if you want a smaller, design-forward hotel in SoHo with a celebrated French restaurant (Le Coucou), an intimate bar/nightclub, and a more neighborhood-driven downtown experience.
When The Peninsula New York wins: choose The Peninsula for a classic Midtown luxury stay with larger property scale, an indoor pool, a full-service spa, multiple bars/lounges, and immediate access to Fifth Avenue shopping and cultural attractions.
Bottom line: both hotels aim at high-end city travel but serve different needs — 11 Howard for boutique downtown style and nightlife/dining; The Peninsula for traditional Midtown luxury and full-service facilities.
| Category | 11 Howard | The Peninsula New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Contemporary SoHo boutique with Scandinavian-influenced design and nightlife | Beaux Arts/5th Avenue classic luxury, formal service |
| Location | SoHo — crossroads of Nolita, Chinatown, Little Italy; Canal St subway nearby | Midtown Manhattan — 5th Avenue at 55th St, steps from MoMA and Rockefeller Center |
| Size | About 207 guest rooms (boutique scale) | 219 guestrooms |
| Check-in minimum age | Primary guest must be 21 to check in; children allowed as accompanying guests | |
| Pool | No on-site pool | Indoor pool available |
| Restaurants & bars | Le Coucou (French, Michelin recognition) + The Library lounge + nightclub/bar | Clement Restaurant (American) + 3 bars/lounges + 24-hour room service |
| Spa & wellness | HigherDOSE infrared sauna suites and lymphatic treatments (on-site); local gym access via destination fee | Full-service spa with massages, body treatments, facials; 24-hour health club |
| Signature strengths | Design-led rooms, Michelin-starred dining, downtown nightlife and private event spaces | Classic Fifth Avenue address, full-service amenities, indoor pool and multiple meeting rooms |
| Accessibility & family | Wheelchair-accessible features; children welcome with adult; dog-friendly (small dogs allowed) | Wheelchair accessible path of travel; family-friendly with children and children’s amenities |
| Parking & transport | Valet parking (surcharge) and nearby off-site parking; Canal St subway a short walk | Valet parking (surcharge), secured parking; central Midtown subway access and walking to attractions |
11 Howard sits in SoHo at Howard and Lafayette, within easy walking distance of neighborhood boutiques and downtown landmarks.
Choose 11 Howard for a downtown, neighborhood-focused stay with strong local character.
The Peninsula New York is on Fifth Avenue at 55th Street, a central Midtown location near MoMA and Rockefeller Center.
Choose The Peninsula when you want Midtown convenience and immediate access to major museums and shopping.
11 Howard offers about 207 rooms and suites with Scandinavian-influenced design and several terrace/large-suite options.
Expect contemporary, design-forward rooms that favor style and downtown proportions.
The Peninsula New York has a traditional five-star room lineup across 219 guestrooms and suites.
Expect classic, spacious-feeling luxury rooms with traditional five-star amenities.
11 Howard centers dining around Le Coucou (French) and The Library lounge — a strong draw for food-focused stays.
Pick 11 Howard if Michelin dining and a compact, high-quality food-and-drink program matter most.
The Peninsula offers a larger, more traditional mix: a main restaurant, three bars/lounges and 24-hour room service.
Choose The Peninsula for a broader set of on-site dining and lounge options in Midtown.
11 Howard does not have an on-site swimming pool, focusing instead on sauna-based wellness.
If a pool is essential, 11 Howard is not the right choice; it emphasizes infrared sauna wellness instead.
The Peninsula New York provides a full-service spa and an indoor pool as part of its facilities.
Choose The Peninsula if on-site pool and comprehensive spa/fitness facilities are priorities.
11 Howard pairs HigherDOSE infrared sauna treatments and a lively on-site bar/nightclub for evening energy.
11 Howard suits guests who want boutique wellness treatments plus an active nightlife on-property.
The Peninsula focuses on a full-service spa, quieter lounge bars and formal service across its public areas.
The Peninsula is a better pick for guests seeking on-site spa treatments and more sedate evening lounges.

11 Howard — Le Coucou holds Michelin recognition and is the hotel's culinary highlight.

The Peninsula New York — indoor pool, full-service spa, multiple bars and a central Fifth Avenue address.

11 Howard — on-site lounge, bar and nightclub make staying late easy.

The Peninsula New York — steps from MoMA, Rockefeller Center and Fifth Avenue shopping.
The Peninsula New York — it's located on Fifth Avenue at 55th Street, within walking distance of MoMA and Rockefeller Center.
No — 11 Howard does not have an on-site pool; it offers HigherDOSE infrared sauna suites instead.
Both hotels allow children as accompanying guests once a qualifying adult has checked in; both have a 21+ minimum for the primary check-in guest.
The Peninsula New York — it has a full-service spa and an indoor pool; 11 Howard offers on-site HigherDOSE sauna suites instead.
Explore how 11 Howard stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·